Paper
Genistein inhibits tumour cell growth in vitro but enhances mitochondrial reduction of tetrazolium salts: A further pitfall in the use of the MTT assay for evaluating cell growth and survival

https://doi.org/10.1016/0959-8049(93)90297-SGet rights and content

Abstract

The natural isoflavone genistein inhibits the growth of a number of tumour cell lines in vitro. During investigations on the antiproliferative effects of genistein we observed that, with respect to direct cell counting, a tetrazolium (MTT) colorimetric assay consistently underestimated the growth inhibitory activity of the substance. Cell proliferation was markedly inhibited by genistein in three tumour cell lines (MCF-7, human breast tumour; Jurkat cells, human T-cell leukaemia; L-929, mouse transformed fibroblasts) when cell number was evaluated by direct counting, whereas a 72-h MTT assay failed to reveal any growth-inhibitory effect. Cell cycle analysis by propidium iodide staining and flow-cytometry revealed a G2/M cell cycle arrest after genistein treatment. Genistein-treated cells displayed an increase in cell volume and in mitochondrial number and/or activity, as revealed by enhanced formazan generation and increased uptake of the vital mitochondrial dye rhodamine 123. These results suggest that alterations in cell cycle phase redistribution of tumour cells by genistein may significantly influence mitochondrial number and/or function and, consequently, MTT reduction to formazan. This may constitute an important bias in analysing the effects of genistein, and possibly other drugs that block the G2/M transition, on growth and viability of cancer cells in vitro by MTT assay.

References (22)

  • MR Boyd

    National Cancer Institute new drug development program

  • Cited by (149)

    • Cell viability and drug evaluation biosensing system based on disposable AuNPs/MWCNT nanocomposite modified screen-printed electrode for exocytosis dopamine detection

      2023, Talanta
      Citation Excerpt :

      In these assays, MTT is very robust and is suitable for most cell lines but with defects of more steps to convert insoluble formazan crystals into soluble formazan using dimethyl sulphoxide (DMSO) [11]. Although the newer alternatives are more sensitive and with the advantage of fewer steps to get results, they often interfere with the pharmacology of target [12–14]. Therefore, the desired cellular response analysis platforms should be characterized by simple, fast, highly sensitive and selective detection, reaching quantitative analyses even in turbid and colored solutions as well as complex biological samples.

    • Effects-directed detection: cell-based assays

      2023, Instrumental Thin-Layer Chromatography, Second Edition
    • DNA binding studies of novel diazatruxenones analogs as potential anticancer agents: Synthesis, antitumor investigation, DNA binding, SAR and molecular modeling calculation

      2020, Bioorganic Chemistry
      Citation Excerpt :

      Furthermore, although compound 8 has even lower concentration than compounds 4 and 6 but it has higher IC50 cytotoxic concentrations. The active compounds 3f, 4–8 were screened for their IC50 values, doxorubicin was used as positive control for the test according to the reported procedure [30,31]. It was revealed that the active compounds 4 and 6 exerted IC50 very close to the standard drug used with values equals 10.63 ± 1.1 and 12.48 ± 2.6 respectively.

    • A novel treatment strategy for preterm birth: Intra-vaginal progesterone-loaded fibrous patches

      2020, International Journal of Pharmaceutics
      Citation Excerpt :

      The cell yields obtained at the end of the culture showed consistent results with 7-day MTT assay as it showed that the fibrous structure of the patches provided additional anchorage points for cells to attach and proliferate, not only on the surface but also within the patch since the number of cells counted on the patches exceeded the number of cells that can possibly proliferate as a monolayer on a 1 cm2 surface (Fig. 9C). Since, the increased cell yield as well as the constant increase in the metabolic activity according to the MTT assay can be interpreted as the increase in the cell number, the cell functionality as well as the cell viability (Pagliacci et al., 1993), it can be concluded that the fibrous patches provided a more suitable environment for cells to stay healthy and viable throughout the course of 7 days. In addition to quantitative assays, the culture was also monitored visually to inspect any changes in morphology of the cells seeded on the produced fibrous patches.

    • Interlink between improved formulations, inhibitory concentrations and cell death mechanism investigations of cytotoxic drugs: What really matters?

      2020, Journal of Controlled Release
      Citation Excerpt :

      Pagliacci et al. observed that genistein inhibited cancer cells growth; however, during the MTT assay, genistein increased the formazan production which causing false negative results. They indicated that genistein increased formazan formation in G2/M arrested tumor cells owing to an enhancement of mitochondrial activity [28]. On the other hand, MTT's lipophilicity can also be problematic.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text